"An acceptable and bittersweet conclusion to the series but overall the book itself plodded along, any action that did take place fell flat and all emotions felt forced and out of character. I just wasn't thrilled with the book itself but the series overall was entertaining."
2 Stars
Pros: It was an acceptable conclusion, bittersweet but understandable.
Cons: I struggled through this novel. I think I wanted more things to happen and it was just a lot of getting from point A to point B/Asriel marshaling all his forces and such just all seemed to kind of peter out/Mary Malone acting "the Serpent" didn't seem to come to anything either.
Full Review:
With the cliff hanger ending of The Subtle Knife the reader is left desperate to know what happened to Lyra etc. Pullman takes care of it all but a lot of it feels forced. Mrs. Coulter's sudden desperate love for Lyra didn't make any sense, since she'd always been so cold and calculating before. Asriel is as indifferent as ever. And the people who actually care about Lyra are no longer players in the game.
A lot of the novel just seemed like it was going from one point to the other, getting Lyra and Will from Point A to Point B. Not much seemed to really happen and what did happen, all seemed kind of glazed over. It all just fell kind of flat and felt disjointed and rushed.
Overall, this was a good conclusion to the series. It was bittersweet, what had to happen, but in the end, you're left feeling a little sad but also hopeful. I think, in the end, this series was about innocence, how as children, we take what we have for granted and then as we grow older and realize we don't have it anymore, we're left reeling. It was a coming of age story and a story about growing up, which is never an easy thing. I enjoyed the series for what it was but I really struggled to get through the last book.
Comments
Post a Comment