Skip to main content

The Finalists by David Bell

"What had potential as a dark academia, suspenseful thriller quickly devolved into a "he said, she said" blame game. ciche, "who dun it" murder mystery. The only reason I finished the book was to find out "who dun it" and it was rather a let down in the end."

1 Star

Pros: The idea of the Hyde Scholarship, the whole process had me intrigued but it quickly lost its edge. 

Cons: The characters couldn't have been anymore cliche or one dimensional. A veteran who insists that everyone call him Captain, the bespectacled, black clad, Doc Marten wearing English Major with tattoo sleeves and the good ol' home grown, American boy, Duffy who works on his family farm and I'm pretty sure, actually said, "Aw shucks" at one point/The fact that no one was ever honest with anyone got really old really quickly and is one of the main reasons I don't really read murder mysteries.   

Full Review

Vincent Gaines, the Vice President of Institutional Development at Hyde College pulls up to Hyde House, eager and excited for this new year and new opportunity. Every year, on the third Saturday of April, six students from six different majors and six obviously different backgrounds all meet at the legendary Hyde House at Hyde College.  They're given the opportunity to compete for the legendary and prestigious Hyde Fellowship. The winner gets the rest of their tuition paid and a guaranteed entry level job at the Hyde Corporation after graduation.  

Of course, it's come to light that Ezekiel Hyde, the founder of Hyde House and the resulting Hyde College, was in the Union army during the Civil War and participated in a slaughtering of Confederate prisoners, so his morality is brought into question. Also the Hyde fortune was founded on Coal, which people thinks is killing the Earth. This year is very different from anything prior since there are now protestors, a police presence and also, Theodore Hyde has passed and the sole survivor and heir of the Hyde fortune is Nicholas Hyde, a perpetually hung over 30 something year old Billionaire playboy. 

Once the process begins, everyone hands over their cell phones and are locked in Hyde House and must remain in the house until 4 pm or everything is null and void. 

They all have Tea, as is customary and Nicholas Hyde does his best to fill in for his Father, playing the role of the Hyde heir. and explaining how the day will proceed. But when one of the students suddenly starts seizing, frothing at the mouth and dies, well, this whole being locked in a house with 7 other people suddenly isn't as appealing as it was. 

The story quickly devolved into a "who dun it" cliche murder mystery and the only reason I kept reading was to find out well, "who dun it." And the revelation at the end made sense but 300+ pages felt like an awfully long time to get to the point. Also, every chapter ended with, "Mr. Gaines, you should come see this" or "Mr. Gaines, I need to speak to you in private." No one was honest with one another and it was all a huge "he said, she said" blame game that got old after 20 pages in. I'd been looking at this book for a long time and now that I've read it, I just wasn't all that impressed. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon

"High Fantasy with lots of interwoven threads of fate getting all knotted up together, as they do. Though Shannon's ambition is incredible and inspiring, in the end it all felt a bit off pace and quickly fell into "information overload."  Pros: High fantasy, true and brilliant world building. You have different kingdoms with their own customs and beliefs, Shannon has truly created something incredible. But this is both a Pro and a Con . Cons : Too many characters to remember/Too many countries/histories/legendary figures to keep track of.  Full Review:  It all starts when Tane breaks her seclusion, wishing to swim in the sea one more time before choosing day. In the morning she'll see if she's earned the revered title of Dragon Rider. But just tonight, she wants to swim and feel free. She's horrified when she runs into a man named Sulyard, who begs for her help.  She helps him asking a childhood friend Susa to take him away and she does, allowing Tane t
Post a Comment
Read more

A Spark of White Fire (The Celestial Trilogy #1) by Sangu Mandanna

"Similar to "Game of Thrones" only in space, there was a lot going on with a lot of different people and they were all important and connected but my tired, overworked brain had trouble keeping up. " 2 Stars  Pros:  I liked Max as a character, I'm all for the tall, dark, mysterious supposed bad boy with a heart of gold cliche, but the kissing cousins thing just made it weird.   Cons:  It felt like Game of Thrones, only in space, so there was a bit of a kissing cousins vibe going and I wasn't feeling it/The book tried to have these big, shocking moments I was just non-plussed, unaffected./The presence of the Gods irked me as they did in The Illiad, it's all terribly convenient to have divine intervention for your MCs. I feel like it's the cheapest fake-out cheat of all time 👍🤣 Full Review:    My co-worker, who has recommended some amazing reads such as, A Man Called Ove ,   The Boy, The Mole, The Fox and the Horse,  and I'll Give You The Sun,  r
Post a Comment
Read more

Peter Pan by J.M. Barrie

"The classic tale of Peter Pan, the boy who never grows up and his adventures with his Lost Boys and the Darling Children, Wendy, John and Michael. At times fun and whimsical and other times surprisingly dark, it was an interesting read as an adult." 3 Stars  Pros:   There is something appealing about flying away to a mysterious island where you can play all day and never have to grow up. The thrall of Neverland is a constant for this dreamer.  Cons: Peter Pan is truly the most arrogant little brat and very much in need of a mother/I was surprised at the bloodshed because I always thought this was a children's book, it was rather dark at times.  Full Review Mr. and Mrs. Darling are the proud yet rather dismissive and negligent parents of three children. Wendy, John and Michael. All three have flights of fancy and dream of an island, with mermaids and pirates. Mrs. Darling dismisses these as the whimsy of childhood but she herself remembers when she too dreamt of the very
Post a Comment
Read more